Big Fish Seafood Grill
Creative seafood platters and elegant presentations in quiet Oyster Pond
Why Go
Big Fish Seafood Grill is the restaurant that justifies driving to Oyster Pond for dinner. On the Dutch side of the island at Emerald Merit Road, it specializes in fresh seafood with creative preparations that go well beyond the standard grilled-fish-with-rice formula. Escargot, crab cakes, salmon with inventive sauces, and stuffed lobster arrive with the kind of plating and attention to detail that signals a kitchen taking itself seriously — in the best possible way.
The Experience
The dining room is refined without being formal, creating an atmosphere appropriate for a special evening out. The menu reads like a chef who loves seafood and wants to show you what's possible — not just cooking fish well, but presenting it beautifully and pairing it with unexpected flavors. Portions are generous, especially on the seafood platters that give you a sampler of the kitchen's range. The Oyster Pond location means it's quieter and less touristy than Simpson Bay or Philipsburg restaurants, attracting diners who are specifically seeking out quality food rather than convenience.
What to Try
The stuffed lobster is a must-try and the dish most talked about by returning guests. The escargot preparation shows French influence that makes sense given the proximity to the French side. Crab cakes are done right — more crab than filler. Ask your server about the chef's specials, which often showcase whatever was freshest that day. Save room for the seafood platter if you're dining with a group.
Insider Tip
Big Fish is dinner only, opening Tuesday through Sunday at 6 PM and closed Mondays. Reservations are smart during high season, especially Friday and Saturday nights. The drive from Simpson Bay takes about 20 minutes and passes through some beautiful scenery. Pair dinner here with an afternoon at nearby Dawn Beach for a full Oyster Pond experience.
The Practical Stuff
Located at 6 Emerald Merit Rd, Oyster Pond. Open Tuesday to Sunday 6 PM to 11 PM, closed Monday. Price range is $$$. Specializes in creative seafood — escargot, crab cakes, stuffed lobster, salmon, and seasonal specials. Beautiful presentation. Reservations recommended. Near Dawn Beach and Oyster Bay Beach Resort. Cards accepted.
Pair It With
- Oyster Bay Beach Resort Guide — Luxury stay within walking distance of the restaurant
- Dawn Beach Guide — Afternoon beach visit before your dinner reservation
- CAPTAIN ALAN'S BOAT CHARTERS Guide — Morning charter followed by an evening seafood feast