Replay Restaurant & Sports Bar
Marina-side sports bar at Simpson Bay Resort with screens and Caribbean eats.
Why Go
Simpson Bay Resort's Marina Plaza serves as a small commercial village within the resort complex, and Replay anchors the dining scene there with a combination that works everywhere: good food, cold drinks, and live sports on multiple screens. This is not a hotel lobby restaurant going through the motions — Replay pulls in both resort guests and outside visitors looking for a reliable spot to watch the game while eating something better than bar snacks.
The Experience
The Marina Plaza setting gives Replay a waterfront-adjacent location with views toward the lagoon and the boats docked at the resort's marina. Multiple TVs ensure that whatever game you are looking for — NFL, NBA, Premier League, MLB — there is a screen showing it. The menu covers the American-Caribbean spectrum that works for a sports bar audience: burgers, wings, grilled seafood, and plates substantial enough to call dinner. Dive Adventures and Aqua Mania Adventures operate from the same marina area, meaning you can book a morning dive or snorkel trip and return to Replay for a late lunch with the afternoon game already underway. The Simpson Bay Resort crowd brings a vacation energy that keeps the atmosphere upbeat without veering into rowdy territory. For Hilton Flamingo Beach guests across the way, Replay offers a dining alternative with more personality than a standard resort restaurant.
What to Try
Ask which games are showing before you sit down — during busy sports weekends, screen allocation matters. The grilled seafood options tend to be the strongest menu items at marina-side restaurants. A bucket of cold beers and a shared appetizer platter works well for groups.
Insider Tip
Marina Plaza has its own parking separate from the main resort entrance — look for signs to the marina. Happy hour timing here can overlap with post-dive and post-snorkel crowds returning from morning excursions, creating a lively atmosphere. Weeknights tend to be quieter and better for settling into a long game.
The Practical Stuff
Location: Simpson Bay Resort Marina Plaza, 37 Billy Folly Road, Simpson Bay, Dutch side. Hours: check locally. Payment: US dollars, major cards accepted. Reservations not usually required.
Pair It With
- Aqua Mania Adventures Guide — Morning snorkel adventure, then sports bar lunch at the same marina
- Dive Adventures Guide — Dive in the morning, replay the highlights over beer and food