Johnny B's Under the Tree
Legendary roadside BBQ from a Simpson Bay fisherman — now evolved but never forgotten
Why Go
Johnny B's Under the Tree is one of Simpson Bay's most legendary food stories. For years, fisherman Johnny served Caribbean barbecue from a roadside spot under a big tree with picnic tables, and people came from across the island for his ribs, oxtail, jerk chicken, and fresh fish pulled straight from the nearby market. The original spot has evolved — Johnny now operates from a sit-down location — but the cooking quality and the reputation remain. This is island food history you can still taste.
The Experience
Johnny's cooking is rooted in the Caribbean BBQ tradition — bold seasoning, slow preparation, and an understanding of meat and fish that comes from decades of practice. The ribs are what built the legend, but the oxtail, grilled chicken, and fresh seafood (lobster, whole fish) are all cooked with the same care. Sides like rice and peas and johnnycakes complete the plate. The original under-the-tree atmosphere may have changed, but Johnny's hands haven't. Portions are generous and the food carries the unmistakable flavor of someone who cooks because they love it.
What to Try
The ribs are the legacy dish — start there. Oxtail done properly is a Caribbean treasure, and Johnny's version is among the best on the island. Fresh fish and lobster connect to his fishing roots. Johnnycakes on the side are the authentic local touch. Ask what he caught or sourced that morning for the freshest option.
Insider Tip
Johnny's current operation may be at Jackfish in the Simpson Bay Market area — verify the latest location before heading out. The original under-the-tree spot created a mystique that follows the food wherever it goes. Locals will point you in the right direction. Lunchtime visits tend to be the best for selection.
The Practical Stuff
Originally at the Simpson Bay Fish Market area. Johnny has relocated to a sit-down location (check locally for current address — possibly Jackfish). Price range is $$. Caribbean BBQ including ribs, oxtail, jerk chicken, grilled fish, lobster. Generous portions. Cash recommended. Check locally for current hours.
Pair It With
- Simpson Bay Fish Market — See where Johnny's story started
- Kim Sha Beach Guide — Beach time before or after your BBQ feast
- Sunita's Taxi and Tours — Arrange island exploration from Simpson Bay