Fat Tony's — New York-Style Pizza in Cupecoy
Big slices, bigger portions, zero pretension.
Why Go
Sometimes you do not want tablecloths and wine pairings. Sometimes you want a Fat Tony special pizza, a pile of wings with hot sauce, and the satisfaction of food made generously and without apology. Fat Tony's on Jordan Road in Cupecoy delivers exactly that.
The Experience
Fat Tony's is the kind of Italian-American spot that every neighborhood needs — the place you call when cooking is not happening, when the craving for a real New York-style pizza hits, or when you need to feed a group without breaking the bank. The menu is built on pizza (thin crust, foldable, with a serious topping selection), calzones, wings in various sauces, subs, pasta dishes, garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and salads for when you need to pretend you are being healthy. Portions are generous and prices are fair, which explains why AUC students, nearby condo residents, and visiting families all consider it a regular stop. Delivery and takeout work as well as dine-in, making it flexible for however your evening is going. The Fat Tony special pizza packs enough toppings to justify the name.
What to Try
The Fat Tony special pizza is the signature — loaded with toppings on a proper New York crust. Wings come with multiple sauce options; ask which is the house favorite. Garlic knots make a cheap, delicious add-on to any order. Calzones are stuffed generously.
Insider Tip
Fat Tony's is a lifesaver for AUC students and condo renters in the Cupecoy-Jordan Village area who need reliable delivery. Order directly rather than through third-party apps for faster service. If dining in, it is casual — do not overdress. The portions are American-sized, so one pizza feeds two normal appetites.
The Practical Stuff
Located at 15 Jordan Rd, Cupecoy. Delivery, takeout, and dine-in available. Moderate pricing ($$). New York-style pizza and Italian-American comfort food. Near Terra Sea Salt wellness and Student Rentals.
Pair It With
- Terra Sea Salt Boutique Wellness Guide — Balance indulgent pizza with a wellness session nearby
- Student Rentals Jordan Village Guide — The go-to pizza spot if you are staying in the area