St Maarten-St Martin
SHOP BEFORE YOU FLY
DUTY-FREE AIRPORT SHOPPING
St Maarten-St Martin
All Insider Guides
DESTINITO INSIDER GUIDE

Dinghy Dairy Bar — Creative Custom Ice Cream in Simpson Bay

Cereal-infused ice cream, unlimited mix-ins, and dogs eat free.

restaurant
custom ice cream cereal ice cream dog-friendly Simpson Bay

Why Go

Dinghy Dairy Bar on Airport Road in Simpson Bay takes ice cream in a creative direction — choose your base, pick from an enormous selection of mix-ins including cereal infusions like Fruity Pebbles, add fresh berries or Oreos, and watch your custom creation get blended. Plus, dogs eat free.

The Experience

Dinghy Dairy Bar is built around customization. Instead of choosing from a preset flavor list, you build your ice cream from a rich, creamy base and an almost overwhelming selection of mix-ins. Cereal-infused options are the signature move — Fruity Pebbles, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, or Oreo pieces blended into the ice cream create flavor combinations that range from nostalgic to innovative. Fresh berries, chocolate chunks, candy pieces, and matcha additions round out the options. The concept encourages experimentation: every visit can produce a completely different flavor. The dog-friendly policy (dogs eat free) has made it a popular stop for the island's pet-owning community. Afternoon and evening hours mean it catches the after-beach and after-dinner crowd.

What to Try

Fruity Pebbles infusion with fresh berries — the signature combination. Oreo mix-in with chocolate base for cookie cream lovers. Matcha ice cream for something different. Ask the staff for their most popular custom combination. Bring your dog for a complimentary scoop.

Insider Tip

Dinghy Dairy Bar opens at 3 PM (noon on weekends), positioning it as an afternoon and evening treat spot. The creative mix-in approach means flavors can get wild — start with a small size to test your combination before committing to a large. Weekend evenings are busiest. The Airport Road location has ample parking.

The Practical Stuff

Located at 46 Airport Road, Simpson Bay. Open Monday through Friday 3 PM to 10 PM, Saturday and Sunday noon to 10 PM. Price range: $$ — custom creations are moderately priced. Cash and cards accepted. Dog-friendly — dogs eat free.

Pair It With